Patriotism June 16, 2009
Posted by yashi2612 in Life, Mauritius.add a comment
What makes one a patriot and what doesn’t?
Some time back, I was discussing government spending in Mauritius on a blog when someone told me that I should not worry about it since I don’t contribute any money to the government coffers. The person was implying that it was none of my business since I was not living in Mauritius. This has happened to me too often. People tend to think of me as a traitor just because I have studied and am now working abroad. They think I don’t have the ‘right’ to discuss Mauritian matters.
These people call themselves patriots. They are the ones who are working in Mauritius, helping the country move forward (apparently) and who, generally hate people who dare to move abroad for studies or work. But this is not patriotism, is it? What is patriotism? In the past, it used to be about fighting colonial rule to free your country from oppression. It was about revolution and about sacrificing your life for your motherland. This definition doesn’t strictly apply anymore. If you work in Mauritius, you are not more patriotic than someone who is working in Singapore. A Chinese factory worker in Mauritius is not more patriotic than I am because he or she is working in Mauritius and paying taxes! Yes, you might be a bit jealous. Yes, you are indeed contributing to the Mauritian economy indirectly. But patriotism is something entirely different.
Mauritius does not have a very high crippling emigration rate. These days it is even harder to move to another country, given the tougher immigration laws in Europe and it is getting more and more appealing to stay, study and work in the country. But if someone thought he or she wants to study abroad and probably work abroad for some time to get some valuable experience, why do people think that person is letting the country down? Most people emigrate due to financial incentives abroad which could improve their fortunes, a significant number of people really want to get the best education and best work experience possible. When confronted with this, most Mauritius-based Mauritians would immediately get on the high horse of pseudo-patriotism and childishly dismiss the emigrants as people who don’t give a damn about the country. This could not be further from the truth as it is pure ignorance.
Patriotism is not a competition. It is not a matter of ‘oh no you work abroad, I work on the Board of Air Mauritius in Mauritius and I am helping the country, what the hell have you done for your country?’ Patriotism is about changing things for the best. It is about making a positive impact in your own way. If you have to arm yourself with the best possible education and experience, then so be it. If you have to live in France for 10 years and then come back better equipped to make a difference, then so be it. Do not judge someone prematurely. Do not view temporary emigration as a sin. Sure, some people will not come back, but why don’t we look at the people who will help? When would we stop whining about those leaving and start taking action or atleast suggest ideas? Why do you want to blacklist people who are abroad? Can’t they help at all? Can’t they initiate a debate or propose an idea? Hell, they could be more patriotic than the person shouting about the glory of the Motherland from the rooftops, clad in the national flag! They could be more patriotic than the person who will tell them not to worry about the future of the country but then would be complaining like bored housewives hooked on Tulsi-related banter!
As a slight variation to JFK’s famous words, ask not what other people are or aren’t doing for the country; ask what you can do for your country. Do not accuse someone else of being unpatriotic until you have accomplished something for your country, and even if you have achieved something, does it make you right or more patriotic to call other people unpatriotic? No it doesn’t!
Patriotism is not what it used to be. It either is too strong and powerful a word to be usable in this day and age or now has a considerably changed definition. Either way, everyone at some point in their life do something good for their country, whether directly or indirectly. Studying or working abroad has absolutely no bearing on how patriotic you are. After all, you might be working in Mauritius in a manner, destructive to the country’s well-being or indeed in a stagnant way. It is all about making a difference when you are best able to do it. Be YOUR best before you can do YOUR best for your country. And if you can’t do it, then no-one should begrudge you. Do you think when Gandhi, Bhagat Singh and Nelson Mandela were campaigning for the end of oppression in their respective countries, they were thinking about those damned people who had ‘abandoned’ the struggle? I don’t think so…
Rant over… I need a cup of very strong tea, no sugar please…
Gulaal: Movie Review June 5, 2009
Posted by yashi2612 in Bollywood, Movies.add a comment
Cast: Kay Kay Menon, Raj Singh Chaudhary, Ayesha Mohan, Aditya Shrivastava, Piyush Mishra
Music: Piyush Mishra
Writers: Anurag Kashyap, Raj Singh Chaudhary
Director: Anurag Kashyap
After Dev D, Anurag Kashyap comes back with a powerful political movie, Gulaal, which means red. As
usual, there are no Khans nor any Kapoors involved. The cast is lead by the fabulously talented Kay Kay Menon.
Synopsis: Dileep Singh (Raj Singh Chaudhary), a simple law student moves to Rajpur in Rajasthan. He gets introduced to Rajput politics via his housemate who gets killed while he is running for a college post. Dileep is then chosen by the Rajputana separatist movement, whose influential leader Dukey Bana (Kay Kay Menon) will use all means available to get the Rajputana region recognised as a state, to run for the election. Dukey Bana’s rival, Karan (Aditya Shrivastava) will do his utmost to foil Dukey’s plans. What follows is a series of political ploys and manipulations as the rivals wrestle for power.
Remarks:
- What a powerful story! Gripping throughout, with multiple subplots and with all characters playing important roles. There are no secondary roles.
- Kashyap’s direction is brilliant as usual. There are subtle details on the screen, here and there, which catch your attention as well as capture the essence of certain scenes. Like when Dileep Singh is going through tough times and the neon lighting which normally reads ‘Hello There’ now has the ‘o’ or ‘t’ signs not working and reads ‘Hell_ _here’. There are loads of these kind of touches to scenes which is the mark of a meticulous director. The lighting is awesome too, with a red glow as the perfect background to some intense scenes.
- Next is the cast. Kay Kay Menon continues to delight with his undeniable talent. The quivering moustache complements the fiery calmness of his character of Dukey Bana. But the one who steals the show is Raj Singh Chaudhary who also wrote the movie and plays Dileep the innocent bespectacled youth who is transformed during the movie. He is not a newcomer but this is his first movie as leading man and he is magnificent. Another promising talent to look out for. I could go on and on about the cast, so high was the level of performance by each and every one of the actors. A special mention for Ayesha Mohan who plays the femme fatale, and a rare female political character in a normally male-oriented genre.
- Least but not last, the music and lyrics of Piyush Mishra! Already a talented dialogue writer, Mishra’s music is at times soulful and at times intense with strong lyrics which do justice to the political feel of the movie. I will definitely be looking out for his music in the future!!
All in all, Gulaal is probably the best political movie I have ever seen. I cannot even think of one drawback of the film. There are bucket loads of swearing, as is customary for a Kashyap offering, but you look past this because the movie itself is too overpowering for you to resist its brilliance. Anurag Kashyap reminds me of a young Ram Gopal Varma, I sincerely hope he doesn’t end up like RGV though, because at the moment, Anurag Kashyap could go on to become a legend of Bollywood. Personally, it makes me an even bigger fan when he is described as the anti Yash Chopra by the Indian press… Let the revolution continue…
Movie Rating: 4 out of 5
